Survivor: All-Stars is the eighth season of Silly Survivor written by LukePrower.
Previous: Survivor: Sesame Street
Next: Survivor: Panem
- Theme: All-Stars Season
- Returning Players
- Four Tribes
- Triple Tribal Council
- Tribe Switch
|West||1st Voted Out|
|South||2nd Voted Out|
|South||3rd Voted Out|
|West||4th Voted Out|
|South||5th Voted Out|
|East||North||6th Voted Out|
|West||North||7th Voted Out|
|West||East||8th Voted Out|
Hundred Acre Woods
|East||North||9th Voted Out|
|Ulysses S. Grant|
|East||West||10th Voted Out|
Hundred Acre Woods
|South||East||West||11th Voted Out|
|West||East||East||12th Voted Out|
|North||North||West||13th Voted Out|
|North||West||East||Ikino||14th Voted Out|
1st Jury Member
|North||East||West||15th Voted Out|
2nd Jury Member
|North||East||East||16th Voted Out|
3rd Jury Member
|South||West||West||17th Voted Out|
4th Jury Member
|Rutherford B. Hayes|
|West||West||East||18th Voted Out|
5th Jury Member
|East||West||West||19th Voted Out|
6th Jury Member
7th Jury Member
Hundred Acre Woods
|North||North||West||20th Voted Out|
8th Jury Member
The host Luke arrived on a beach in Pearl Islands of Panama, where separate boats containing twenty-one former Survivor players deemed to be the best of the best, or "All-Stars", arrived. From The Hundred Acre Woods were Gopher, Pooh and Rabbit. From Elwood were Francine, Muffy and Sue Ellen. From USA were Abraham Lincoln, James Madison and Ronald Reagan. From Sound Stage were Elvis Presley, Klaus Nomi and Paul Simon. From Bikini Bottom were Plankton, Spongebob Squarepants and Squidward Tentacles. From Doctors were Paul McGann, Tom Baker and William Hartnell. From Sesame Street were Elmo, Kermit and Oscar. The twenty-one were excited to compete in the biggest and best season of the show ever, but Luke revealed that the cast was not yet complete. Arriving in a helicopter were three "wild cards." People not chosen originally to be in the cast, but showed much potential as players. These revealed to be Rutherford B. Hayes and Ulysses S. Grant from USA and Art Garfunkel from Sound Stage. The players were shocked to discover they would be in four tribes of six, as no season ever had more than two starting tribes. The North tribe contained all winners; Lincoln, Elvis, Pooh, Squidward, Sue Ellen and William. The West tribe contained Francine, Kermit, Nomi, Rutherford, Spongebob and Tom. The East tribe contained Gopher, Oscar, Simon, Plankton, Reagan and Ulysses. The South tribe contained Garfunkel, Elmo, Madison, Muffy, Paul and Rabbit. The tribes headed to their beaches, all twenty-four ready to win.
The North tribe came to an agreement not to form any alliances before going to Tribal, and to stick together come merge or switch. The West tribe began goofing off and mocking the other tribes, with only Rutherford seemingly taking the game seriously. On East, Plankton and Simon approached each other to start the "Evil" alliance, being seen as two of the biggest villains in the history of the game. Ulysses feared Reagan, knowing how tough of a player he was back in their season. On South, everyone feared Elmo knowing he had a history of sabotaging his tribe. Madison and Rabbit then had a power struggle early on, disagreeing on who should run camp. At Immunity, North finished first, followed by South and East. The goofy West tribe had to vote the first person out of the game. Rutherford wanted to vote Spongebob out, viewing him as taking the game the least seriously. However, Spongebob and Kermit had decided to target Francine, who was too abrasive. Not wanting to play too hard too early; Francine, Nomi and Tom sided with Rutherford and Spongebob was the first All-Star voted out.
With one down, West decided to take things more seriously. Francine created a duo alliance with Rutherford, and they brought Tom in as a third member for good measure. The target was now on Kermit. North and East kept their morale high, allowing North to win Immunity once again, followed by West and East. South going into Tribal, it was a tossup. Madison and Rabbit targeted each other, but everyone feared Madison after his performance in USA. Garfunkel and Paul decided to team up against Madison, causing Madison to go after Paul. Garfunkel, Paul and Rabbit voted Madison, expecting a tie with Madison, Elmo and Muffy voting Paul. However, Elmo wanted to play sneakily and threw a vote at Garfunkel, eliminating Madison in a 3-2-1 vote. Muffy was seemingly on the bottom, but the main alliance of Garfunkel, Paul and Rabbit now viewed Elmo as unpredictable. North continued to dominate, followed by West and East. Muffy began targeting Rabbit, Elmo agreeing to vote with her. Seeing Muffy play hard, Garfunkel and Paul decided to vote her instead of Elmo. Rabbit, confused, still voted Elmo. This tied the votes 2-2-1. In the revote, Elmo continued to vote Rabbit, but Garfunkel and Paul voted Muffy out of the game. Rabbit then explained his confusion to Garfunkel and Paul, who welcomed him back into the alliance, leaving Elmo on the outs. Angered by being on the outs, Elmo dumped the rice, which surprised no one.
West, North and South won Immunity, sending East to Tribal. Not trusting Reagan, Ulysses went after him. In return, Reagan targeted Ulysses. Plankton and Simon joined Ulysses, while Oscar and Gopher joined Reagan. After tying the votes and rocks being threatened, no one flipped. East drew rocks, and Oscar drew the purple rock and was eliminated. Reagan was now in trouble. South, North and East won Immunity, as Tom began acting strange. Francine and Rutherford continued their target on Kermit, who Tom began strategizing with. The two thought it best to drop Tom and bring Nomi in instead. This proved to be smart, as Tom flipped and voted Francine. However, Kermit and Nomi seized the opportunity and voted Tom out of the game. Nomi took his place in the alliance, leaving Kermit still on the bottom. East, West and North sent South back to Tribal, Elmo seemed to be the prime target. Elmo campaigned hard against Paul, but it was futile and Elmo was unanimously voted out.
With eighteen remaining, the four tribes were brought together and dissolved into three tribes. The new North tribe consisted of Lincoln, Elvis, Gopher, Kermit, Pooh and Reagan. The new East tribe consisted of Francine, Nomi, Simon, Rabbit, Squidward and Sue Ellen. The new West tribe consisted of Garfunkel, Paul, Plankton, Rutherford, Ulysses and William. At North, Lincoln brought fellow winners Elvis and Pooh into an alliance. Reagan and Kermit feared the winners, so they formed a trio with Gopher. On East, Nomi used his connection with Simon to bring him into his alliance with Francine. Winners Squidward and Sue Ellen agreed to stick together. On West, Garfunkel and Paul reunited, while Rutherford teamed up with Ulysses. Plankton, seeking an ally desperately, went to William. West and East won Immunity, sending North to Tribal Council. Viewing Pooh as the weakest winner, Reagan began targeting him with Gopher and Kermit. Knowing Reagan's strength as a player, Lincoln decided to turn against his former season rival. Fearing a tie, Gopher and Kermit voted with the winners and Reagan was voted out. East and West won once again, sending North back to Tribal. Kermit had now become the number one target of the winner alliance, and set his sights on Lincoln. Kermit had Gopher, as he convinced Elvis that Lincoln was too threatening to keep. However, he was unable to convince Pooh. Luckily for Lincoln, Gopher didn't comprehend the plan and voted Pooh. This tied the votes between Kermit and Lincoln, but Elvis flipped back in the revote and Kermit was voted out, taking out the last player from Sesame Street. Gopher was left alone with three fierce winners, but Elvis was now a traitor to Lincoln and Pooh.
Everyone was shocked to hear a new twist that all three tribes would be attending Tribal Council, competing for individual Immunity. Pooh won on North, Francine won on East and Rutherford won on West. At East; Francine, Nomi and Simon came up with a plan to vote out Rabbit, who seemed out of place at the tribe. Sue Ellen and Squidward, however, wanted to vote out Nomi for being a known flipper from his last season. Rabbit was left in the dark of the plans. At North, Gopher tried to convince Elvis and Pooh once again to flip on Lincoln. At West, Rutherford and Ulysses teamed up against Garfunkel and Paul, while Plankton and William were left in the dark and trying to figure out what was going on. At East's Tribal, Nomi flipped on the Rabbit vote and voted Simon. Not knowing who to vote, Rabbit voted Sue Ellen. Francine and Simon voted Rabbit, while Sue Ellen and Squidward voted Nomi. The votes tied, and Francine and Simon were angered by Nomi flipping. In the revote, Squidward confusedly flipped to vote Rabbit, while Francine and Simon flipped on the traitor to vote with Sue Ellen. Rabbit was saved as Nomi was eliminated. North attended Tribal next and had an easy unanimous vote to vote out Gopher, leaving three winners alone on the tribe. West attended last, as Plankton threw a vote at William to make him paranoid. Rutherford and Ulysses voted Garfunkel, while Garfunkel and Paul voted Ulysses. Unknowingly, William voted Paul. The votes were tied between Garfunkel and Ulysses. No one wanted to go to rocks, so Rutherford and William flipped and they voted out Ulysses.
With thirteen players remaining twenty-four days into the game, everyone was startled to hear about another tribe switch. Three tribes became two. The new East tribe was Lincoln, Francine, Paul, Simon, Rutherford, Sue Ellen and William. The new West tribe was Garfunkel, Elvis, Plankton, Pooh, Rabbit and Squidward. On East, Sue Ellen brought Lincoln and William into a winner trio. Francine and Rutherford, reunited at last, teamed up once again. On West, Plankton went to Squidward to resurrect their duo from the previous season. Garfunkel attempted to bring Plankton and Rabbit into an alliance to take on the three winners of their tribe, and Plankton insisted that he could bring in Squidward. After East won Immunity, West was sent to Tribal Council. Elvis, Pooh and Squidward decided to vote together, aiming for Rabbit, who had been a target for a while. Pooh was evasive about voting his friend, but he knew it was a game. Squidward told Plankton the plan, but Plankton had other ideas. Plankton found it sneaky to vote the leader Garfunkel, leaving Squidward in between plans. Garfunkel and Rabbit had agreed to vote Pooh, but Plankton manipulated Rabbit into believing Garfunkel was plotting against him and targeting him. At Tribal, Rabbit voted Garfunkel with Plankton while Garfunkel voted Pooh. Squidward then flipped to the winners, sending Rabbit out in a 3-2-1 vote, and leaving both Garfunkel and Plankton angered for different reasons.
The tribes found out that they would be attending a double Tribal and competing for individual Immunity. Simon and Garfunkel won Immunity for their respective tribes, as the storm began. On East, Sue Ellen conspired with Lincoln and William to vote out Francine, a strong power player from both of her seasons. Francine and Rutherford also conspired, going after powerhouse Lincoln. Simon met with Paul, and suggested voting out Francine or Rutherford, as they're both power players and a strong duo. Paul, however, wanted William out for being a very smart winner. Simon convinced William that they had to vote Rutherford, as William eventually gave in and agreed. On West, Garfunkel put his anger at Plankton aside, knowing they needed to work together. They considered voting all three winners, but figured Elvis was the most charismatic and potentially most threatening at the merge. Plankton gave Squidward one last chance to redeem their alliance by voting Elvis with him. Squidward then attempted to confuse the other winners, telling Pooh to vote Plankton and Elvis to vote Pooh, who was plotting against them. At East's Tribal, the votes fell 2-2-1 and forced a revote. Seeing an opportunity to take Francine out, Paul and Simon voted her, while William threw his vote to Lincoln. Rutherford received no votes in the revote, but he was left alone when Francine was eliminated. At West's Tribal, all went according to plan when Squidward joined Garfunkel and Plankton. Elvis was voted out in a 3-1-1 vote, being the first winner to fall.
With ten people left, two tribes became one on day twenty-nine. Plankton named the merged tribe "Ikino", a word he had made up. Making up half the tribe, Sue Ellen proposed that the five winners stick together. The other five, however, began thinking of ways to get rid of the winners. Garfunkel reunited with Paul, and the two agreed to go to final two together officially. Simon also approached Garfunkel to work together, but Garfunkel did not trust Simon after his betrayal in their last season. After Lincoln won the first individual Immunity, havoc broke loose, with Lincoln being the intended target of the non-winners. The non-winners decided between voting the other winner leader figure Sue Ellen or very smart William. Squidward, still trusting Plankton, decided to flip on the winners, expecting Plankton to stay true to their alliance. Not trusting Squidward, Pooh was easily convinced by Simon that the majority was going for Sue Ellen. With time running out, Pooh had to make a move of desperation to side with the votes against Sue Ellen or continue with the winner's plans to vote Plankton or Simon. Feeling resistance was futile, the duo of Pooh and Lincoln settled on having to vote Sue Ellen, being joined by William. Meanwhile, Sue Ellen was informed that the winners were targeting her and the only way to save herself was to vote William. Going out on a whim, they all stuck to their votes. Ultimately, the majority fell on William and he became the first member of the Jury. The winners were down four to five, and torn apart.
Plankton won Immunity, as he and Simon began conspiring about ditching Squidward for being unpredictable. The non-winners informed Squidward that they would vote the vulnerable leader Lincoln. However, the winners viewed keeping their alliance as futile and turned on Squidward, unanimously voting him out. Right afterwards, the players were shocked to discover they would be voting another person out. Names flew around, and the target appeared to be either Lincoln, Pooh or Sue Ellen, all of whom were major threats in different ways. Sue Ellen desperately voted Pooh, but was unanimously eliminated. Lincoln and Pooh, the dynamic duo, were left as the only winners remaining.
After Paul won Immunity, his cockiness rose. Knowing Lincoln and Pooh could be useful, Simon conspired with Paul, Plankton and Rutherford about backstabbing Garfunkel. With his loyalty to Garfunkel, Paul brought the word to him, causing Garfunkel to flip out at Simon in front of everyone. An argument commenced, but the two later made up in private, with Simon claiming it was just a "suggestion." Nonetheless, Simon went to Lincoln and Pooh to vote Garfunkel out together, since the non-winners intended to vote Pooh. Garfunkel and Plankton voted Pooh, while at last minute Simon convinced Paul that the target was Rutherford, in an attempt to keep him from ruining the plan. Rutherford, left out of the loop, voted Lincoln. With Paul voting Rutherford and Simon voting Garfunkel with the winners, Garfunkel was betrayed and eliminated. Not even his number one ally Plankton trusted Simon anymore.
Plankton successfully won Immunity, while Simon knew his only hope for survival now would be to stick with the winners. Lincoln, Simon and Pooh's plan became to vote either Paul or Rutherford, who could easily ruin their games. Plankton, not knowing whether or not to trust Simon, decided to give him one last chance and vote Paul with him. Purposely going for a tie, Simon voted Paul with Plankton while leaving Lincoln and Pooh voting Rutherford. Paul and Rutherford, on the outs, respectively voted Simon and Pooh. In the tie between Rutherford and Paul, Simon acted as if he had no idea what happened. Confused, the winners continued to vote Rutherford in the revote, while Plankton continued to vote Paul. Simon flipped to the winners, voting Rutherford out of the game. Returning to camp, Simon was able to pass it off to Plankton that he didn't know what to do. Plankton still did not trust Simon.
Pooh secured his spot in the season finale with Immunity, while Simon figured it would be best to eliminate the last "not big" player Paul, thus having a powerhouse final four. However, Lincoln and Pooh contemplated blindsiding major villain Plankton, concerned about his connections to Simon and the possibility of him winning. Still knowing how threatening Simon was, Paul came after him. Plankton, on the other hand, feared Lincoln would be the most likely to win. They all went through with their voting plans, and powerhouse villain Plankton was voted out in a 2-1-1-1 vote.
In the season finale, Simon knew he was on the outs. He attempted to align with adversary Paul, knowing it was winners vs. non-winners once again, and they were even. With Lincoln winning Immunity, allegiances crumbled. Lincoln wanted Paul out, while Pooh wanted Simon out. They couldn't come to a reasonable conclusion, and voted their own ways. Paul and Simon voted with the respective people trying to save them, forcing themselves into a fire-making tiebreaker. An intense match broke out, but just barely Simon completed the fire and eliminated Paul, going to the final three with Lincoln and Pooh. After paying respects to the fallen players, the final three took part in the Final Immunity Challenge. Pooh dropped out early, as Lincoln and Simon faced off for hours. Eventually, Simon slipped and Lincoln won the final Immunity. Having to decide on bringing his number one ally to the game or the person he could easily win against, Lincoln found himself between a rock and a hard place. Ultimately, he figured the Jury would hate Simon and love Pooh, so he betrayed Pooh and brought Simon to the final two.
The final day of the game, Lincoln and Simon enjoyed their second time in the final two, especially in an All-Star season. They had breakfast, burned the camp down and headed for Final Tribal Council. When facing the Jury, both received equal praise and criticism. However, Simon was criticized for his major flippy and inconsistent game. Months later, the votes were read in front of a live audience. By a 6-2 Jury vote, Abraham Lincoln won his second season of Survivor and became the All-Star winner.
|1||"Welcome Back"||None||North, South, East||Spongebob||4-2||1st Voted Out|
|2||"Can't Tolerate This"||None||North, West, East||James||3-2-1||2nd Voted Out|
|3||"I'm So Done With You"||South||North, West, East||Muffy||2-2-1;|
|3rd Voted Out|
|4||"Down, But Ain't Out"||None||West, North, South||Oscar||3-3;|
|5||"Out of His Environment"||East||South, North, East||Tom||4-1||4th Voted Out|
|6||"Cut the Cancer"||East||East, West, North||Elmo||3-1||5th Voted Out|
|7||"Switched and Swapped"||None||West & East||Ronald||5-1||6th Voted Out|
|8||"Winners Always Win"||East||East & West||Kermit||2-2-1;|
|7th Voted Out|
|9||"Three Times the Fun"||None||Pooh, Rutherford, Francine||Klaus|
|8th Voted Out|
9th Voted Out
10th Voted Out
|10||"Damn It"||None||East||Rabbit||3-2-1||11th Voted Out|
|11||"Feels Like It's Been Twenty Years"||None||Paul S. & Art||Francine|
|12th Voted Out|
13th Voted Out
|12||"A Word I Made Up"||None||Abraham||William||7-3||14th Voted Out|
1st Jury Member
|13||"Can't Catch a Break"||None||Plankton||Squidward|
|15th Voted Out|
2nd Jury Member
16th Voted Out
3rd Jury Member
|14||"Picking Them Off"||None||Paul M.||Art||3-2-1-1||17th Voted Out|
4th Jury Member
|15||"On Rough Terrain"||None||Plankton||Rutherford||2-2-1-1;|
|18th Voted Out|
5th Jury Member
|16||"They're Done For"||None||Pooh||Plankton||2-1-1-1||19th Voted Out|
6th Jury Member
|17||"Fifty Ways to Leave Survivor"||None||Abraham||Paul M.||2-2;|
7th Jury Member
|None||Abraham||Pooh||1-0||20th Voted Out|
8th Jury Member